© Reuters. FILE PHOTO: People queue to use WorldCoin’s iris-scanners in Madrid, Spain, March 6, 2024. REUTERS/ Antoine Demaison
By Emma Pinedo and Elizabeth Howcroft
MADRID (Reuters) – Spain’s High Court on Monday upheld a temporary ban on Worldcoin’s iris-scanning venture, the latest blow to a project that has sparked privacy concerns in several countries.
The court said the “safeguarding of the public interest” must prevail, dismissing an appeal by Worldcoin’s owners who asked for the ban to be lifted while it deliberates.
Co-founded by OpenAI CEO Sam Altman in 2019, Worldcoin aims to create a global identity system by getting people to have their irises scanned in exchange for free cryptocurrency and a digital ID.
The venture was temporarily banned on Wednesday by Spain’s privacy watchdog following complaints of insufficient information, the collection of data from minors and not allowing the withdrawal of consent.
The watchdog said the processing of biometric data, which has special protection under the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation, “entails high risks for people’s rights, taking into account their sensitive nature”.
It told Worldcoin to stop collecting personal information and stop using data it had already gathered.
Worldcoin said in a statement on its website that Spain’s regulator had circumvented the “accepted EU process and rules”, without giving further details.
The company argued that the regulator’s decision “would cause it enormous damage and irreparable harm both in Spain and worldwide,” the court said.
It also argued the court was not competent and that the data agency in the German state of Bavaria, where the company is based, should be in charge of assessing whether the company complies with data protection regulations.
On Monday, a Worldcoin spokesperson said the firm was fully compliant with all laws and regulations governing biometric data collection and data transfer.
“We look forward to the opportunity to demonstrate this compliance and provide the regulator with accurate and important information regarding this essential and lawful technology in the Spanish High Court,” the spokesperson added.
More than four million people in 120 countries have signed up to have their irises scanned by Worldcoin, according to its website and queues of people eager to sign up to try out the new tool have formed in Spanish metro stations in recent weeks.
But the project has drawn criticism from privacy campaigners from Argentina to Germany over the collection, storage and use of personal data.
Spain’s High Court said that in the event of an eventual favourable judgment lifting the ban, the company would be compensated for any lost income, thereby rejecting the argument of “irreparable damage” alleged by the appellant.
