Did you know you can customize Google to filter out garbage? Take these steps for better search results, including adding my work at Lifehacker as a preferred source.
With Halloween around the corner, let’s take a look at a spooky and supposedly true story going viral this week. Recently, a 911 call surfaced of a North Carolina man calling authorities because he thought he saw a bloody man by the side of a desolate country road. While he was speaking to the operator, something landed in the bed of his pickup truck, causing the 911 caller to start screaming “It’s not human! It’s not human!”
Check out the video:
My first reaction upon seeing this was the same as yours: It’s fake. Compelling, sure. but fake, like 100,000 other online “paranormal videos.” There’s no picture of the creature. We don’t know who the guy is. We don’t know the context. There’s no effort and no risk in making and posting a video online, so there’s no reason to think it’s real, so I swiped to the next video. But it turns out there’s enough evidence here that it at least deserves a deeper look.
The true part of the story
Unlike the overwhelming majority of spooky videos posted online, a big part of this story is true. It’s a real recording of a 911 call placed at 11 p.m. on July 31, 2021 in Pender County, North Carolina. The verifiable details that the caller reported in the call are accurate too. Snopes listened to the entire 11-minute 911 call, and cross-checked the details to make sure the distance the caller said he’d driven check out, and they do.
The caller didn’t hang up, either. He waited around for Pender County Sheriff’s department officers to arrive, and he cooperated with the investigation. This means an actual person out there is willing to stand behind the story—that’s a much higher level of evidence than most paranormal claims online have. The cops didn’t find anything, but that was in keeping with the 911 call, too: Dude said he slammed on the brakes and the inhuman thing in his truck bed flew out, landed on the road, and took off into the woods.
“It’s some yahoo calling in a hoax report to 911,” you might be saying. Fair point, but that’s a crime, and the unnamed caller was apparently believable enough that he wasn’t arrested for filing a bogus police report. The sheriff took the incident seriously enough to open up a file about it, use state resources to look into it, and later do a media interview.
How much evidence is enough evidence?
If the 911 caller had been reporting something else in this call, like a wounded deer in the highway or something, we wouldn’t question whether it actually happened. The recording and the police report would be overkill; we’d believe the guy just because he said it happened.
What do you think so far?
But I’m still 99.99% sure this guy either mistook something mundane for a monster or made up a tale entirely.
According to the 911 caller, the thing in the back of his pickup truck had shallow sunken eyes, and no nose, like someone had “taken skin and put it on a human skull and stretched it thin.” It was not human. As Carl Sagan once said, “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence” and a mystery creature in South Carolina would certainly be extraordinary. If it was true, it would upend everything we know about biology, zoology, evolution, and North Carolina. I’m open to the possibility, but we need more than a 911 call to accept it. We’d need extraordinary evidence: video, photos, corroborating witnesses, and physical evidence wouldn’t even be enough. You’d have to catch one before it would make sense to rewrite the zoology textbooks.
There actually could be a monster in North Carolina
Don’t lose hope, all you “I want to believe” people. It could still be real. Up until the mid-1800s, gorillas were basically Bigfoot, as far as Western science was concerned: A few people told tales of spotting them deep in the jungle, but there wasn’t a compelling reason to think they existed. Same with giant squids: Occasionally a sailor would swear he encountered one, but it wasn’t until the 1840s that there was physical evidence, and we didn’t have a photo of a giant squid until 2004.
Yeah, a previously undiscovered creature would have a harder time hiding out in modern North Carolina than gorillas had staying scarce in Cameroon in the 1840s, but it’s October, so I’m calling it a (barely, technically possible) mystery instead of an outright lie.
